RecallSep 8, 2026FI Supplements: Potential to be contaminated with Salmonella
913 products scored225 ingredients explainedNo paid placement

Ingredient library

Worth knowing · Color additive

Added color

Also appears on labels as: added color, added colors, fda approved colors, colorant, caramel color, chlorophyll (color)

Color added so the product looks a certain way to the person buying it. Caramel color, titanium dioxide, iron oxides, annatto and carmine are the usual ones; a plain "added color" on a label does not say which.

Watched ingredients get highlighted on every product panel you open.

Where it comes from
Varies: caramel color is cooked sugar, titanium dioxide and iron oxides are mineral pigments, annatto comes from achiote seeds, and carmine from cochineal insects.
Why it's in the product
Appearance. Nothing else.
Safety and toxicity
Most are color additives that FDA exempts from batch certification, unlike synthetic dyes such as Red 40. We flag them for the same reason we flag dyes: they do nothing for the pet.
Interactions and who should be careful
Your pet does not care what color the food is. An additive that exists only for the buyer's eye earns a caution flag.

General reference, not veterinary advice. Dose, breed, and existing conditions change the answer, so talk to your vet before changing what your pet eats. Think we got this wrong? Tell us and we log it publicly.

Found in 62 scored products

We flag it by name on 50 of them. Lowest scores first.

Panel Score 51 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Milk-BoneSoft & Chewy Training Mini, Filet Mignon

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 55 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Milk-BoneFlavor Snacks Dog Biscuits

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 55 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Milk-BoneMaroSnacks With Real Bone Marrow

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 56 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Pup-PeroniOriginal Beef Flavor

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 56 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Beggin'Thick Cut Hickory Smoke Flavor

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 60 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Gravy TrainChunks In Gravy With Beef Chunks

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 60 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Beggin'Flavor Stix With Peanut Butter Flavorimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 67 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Fancy FeastClassic Paté Chicken Feast

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 68 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
9LivesPaté With Real Chicken

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 68 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
9LivesHearty Cuts With Real Turkey, Chicken & Cheese In Gravyimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
CesarFilet Mignon Flavor Wet Dog Food

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
CesarClassic Loaf in Sauce Grilled Steak & Eggs Flavorimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Fancy FeastCreamy Delights Chicken Feast with a Touch of Real Milkimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Fancy FeastKitten Tender Chicken Feastimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Fancy FeastKitten Tender Ocean Whitefish Feastimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Meow MixTenders In Sauce With Real Chicken & Beefimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
FriskiesLil' Slurprises With Surimi Whitefish In A Dreamy Sauceimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
FriskiesTasty Treasures Accented With Bacon Turkey Dinner In Gravyimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 71 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
FriskiesWarm'd & Serv'd Grill'd Bites With Chicken In Gravyimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 72 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Gravy TrainMeaty Ground Dinner With Beef & Bacon

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 75 out of 100, grade B: Good, check the flags
BenefulOriginals With Farm-Raised Beef

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 75 out of 100, grade B: Good, check the flags
NudgesGrillers Chicken Jerky

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 75 out of 100, grade B: Good, check the flags
TemptationsSeafood Medley Cat Treats

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 75 out of 100, grade B: Good, check the flags
BenefulIncrediBites With Farm-Raised Chicken

flagged on this product's score page

38 more scored products list this ingredient. Showing the 24 lowest-scoring.