RecallSep 8, 2026FI Supplements: Potential to be contaminated with Salmonella
913 products scored225 ingredients explainedNo paid placement
Front of the packageWet cat food · can
9Lives Paté With Real Chicken, front of the package
Turn it over: every ingredient is below
9LivesBrand transparency D

Paté With Real Chicken

Wet cat food · canCat foodScored November 2026

Panel Score 68 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Flags
55 caution
Ingredients
20all in our library
Brand grade
Dtransparency, costs 8 points
Recalls
0linked to this product
Dispute this score

Save it to your pantry and the pantry page flags it if it turns up in an FDA recall we import.

Why 6896 to start

It adds up, line by line.

Every product starts at 96. Flags, the brand's transparency grade and any recall linked to this product take points away. Nothing else moves the number, and no brand can pay to move it.

Tap a line on the receipt to see which ingredients caused it.

The full methodology
Check the PanelScore receipt

9Lives
Paté With Real Chicken

Starting point96
Brand transparency · D-8
Documented recall · none0
Panel Score68 C

Proceed with caution

Scored November 2026 · checkthepanel.com

Flags-20 points in all

5 flagged ingredients.

Avoid first. Each flag costs points in the score above; where a flag has an entry behind it, it links to the evidence.

Caution-4

Meat by-products

Unnamed animal parts. Legal and regulated, but the label tells you nothing about the source.

Caution-4

Added color

Color added for the buyer's eye, not a synthetic dye; your pet does not care what color it is.

Caution-4

Carrageenan

A seaweed thickener linked to gut inflammation in some lab studies.

Caution-4

Menadione (vitamin K3)

A synthetic vitamin K linked to liver stress in high doses; safer natural forms exist.

Caution-4

Sodium nitrite

A curing salt that can form nitrosamines under heat; levels are legally capped.

IngredientsAs published by the brand · 20 lines

Every ingredient, top to bottom.

Listed by weight, so the first few lines are most of the food. Tap any line to see what it is and why it's there.

20 ingredients. 5 of them carry this product's 5 flags and are marked below. The other 15 raised no flag.

Checked against the brand's own page on Nov 7, 2026. A package on the shelf can be older or newer than that page; trust the one in your hand.

RecallsFrom FDA notices

Recall record.

This product

None linked

We link recalls by hand from FDA notices. Only a recall linked to this product counts in its score.

See all pet recalls

9Lives, the brand

No FDA recalls on file

None of the FDA recall notices we have imported names 9Lives.

Brand4 9Lives products scored

The brand behind it.

DTransparency

9Lives

Grocery cat food built on corn gluten meal, meat and bone meal, and color.

Corn base with unnamed meal, BHA/BHT, and multiple dyes. The D grade takes 8 points off this product's score.

9Lives brand page

Independent testing & contaminants

No independent testing on file.

Third-party lab findings for things that never appear on an ingredient label. This is separate from the score above and does not change it.

We haven't found published third-party lab results (PFAS, heavy metals, phthalates) for this product. That is not a clean bill of health, just an absence of data.

What we look for
Cleaner picksChosen by score alone

Cleaner picks in cat food.

Cleaner picks are the highest-scoring products in the same category that suit the same animal. No affiliate links, no paid placement.

Panel Score 96 out of 100, grade A: Pretty good
Feline NaturalChicken & Lamb Feast
Wet food · 3 oz can
Panel Score 96 out of 100, grade A: Pretty good
Open FarmHarvest Chicken Rustic Blend Wet Cat Food
Wet cat food · 5.5 oz cartons, case of 12
Panel Score 94 out of 100, grade A: Pretty good
Tiki CatPuka Puka Luau Succulent Chicken
Wet food · 2.8 or 6 oz cans

No corrections on this page yet.

Holding the package and it reads differently? Disputes come straight to us, and any score we change is logged publicly on the corrections page.